Skip to main content

3D Printed Space Elf DLP, an Actual Comparison.

I got my second pylon from a 3D printer back today.  I thought I would take a few pictures and then give my impressions of the comparative quality and value of the "prints".  I will eventually gather all of this information into a single page one all my items come in.  Now onto the comparison.
We can see that when placed together they initially appear identical other than their color.  I'm still sad about the dimensional mistake on the powerfields, but the angle is correct and both pylons match it exactly.

The greenish pylon is from Ponoko and uses their Durable Fine Plastic.  The white pylon is from Sculpteo and uses their Detail Resin.  Both of these materials are resins extruded from a print head that are then cured with UV light. 
 

 
Both are fairly expensive, with the green pylon costing about $19 and the white pylon costing about $25.  You might think that I would recommend Ponoko over Sculpteo at this point, but if you look at the below picture, the channels between panels appear larger on the green pylon.  They are, and while this might actually make me more likely to try casting the green pylon, it is clear to me that Sculpteo's additional cost does result in a higher quality and more accurate reproduction of the .stl file submitted.  Also on the back of the pylon at the sharp curving edge, you can see a bit of flash on the green pylon that is not present on the white pylon.

 
It's still pretty cool that my idea that became a sculpture then a 3d file is now a printable object that I have held in my hand.  You can have one too if you want.  Here is the white pylon, and here is the green one.  I am trying less expensive materials, so stay tuned if these prices are too steep for you.
 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Building our Ruined Building Part 3

Welcome back,  we are ready to add some battle damage to our perfectly rectangular wall sections and get our ruined building finished up.

My tools used were a cordless drill with a 3/8" (10mm) bit and a pair of diagonal wire cutters.  Before I began, I coated all of the foam in PVA glue and a liberal dusting of sand.  I also coated the upper floors to add some texture.  I also used many pieces of cut up sprue to fill in the gaps where it might not be obvious that models were not supposed to be placed in that spot.  I took some pieces of sprue and used them to brace the upper floors.  Although the for sale sign was good thick plastic, it still flexed enough to concern me.  I used super glue to hold the sprue in place.  In the below view you can see the post added to support both levels.  A wire rope with knots was added for decoration.

You can see how the walls not have jagged edges and there are holes from shells drilled though the walls.  The amount of destruction is really a ma…

A look at some Citadel Paints

I was using some of my paints today and noticed something very interesting about the new paint range.  Not all of the pots are made equal.

If you look at #6, inside the blue circle is a cap hold upon device that uses friction to hold the cap open.  Its like a little rubber ramp.  Number 7, bought from the same store doesn't have it.  I bought 4 paints just recently and two had them and two didn't.  And it was random, I bought 2 base colors and only one had the ramp.  The layer I bought had one, but the technical primer did not.

Citadel Piants have 2 problems that I'll discuss:

1. A problem that arises with all of these paints is that when shaken up, a fair amount of paint sticks to the lid and then drips.  Where it drips depends on the cap design.  All of these caps are designed with an inner protrusion that is meant to direct the cap paint back into the bottle.  Lets look at them by type:
The inner protrusion fits snugly against the cap, so almost all of the paint drains …

A Ruined Manufactorum

It is finished.  Or wrecked?  Maybe completely wrecked?  Anyway, I have put enough details, paint etc on the second mega-terrain tile that it is certainly in playable condition.  Because I'm sure you want to get to the pictures, here they are:

Before:



More after the jump!